Why does he react this way? He remains uninvolved in the petty rivalries and power plays of the inhabitants of Salem. Yet it is a commandment that is sorely neglected today. Explain the irony of Proctor’s forgotten commandment. What news does Hale reveal that shocks the Proctors? Hale's purpose, then, in asking John to recite the Ten Commandments is to test John's devotion to the faith -- he ought to have such a basic list committed to memory if he is a true believer. Why is the presence of a poppet in the Proctor house an important piece of “evidence”? It is a commandment positioned in a place of special honor and significance. Top subjects are Literature, History, and Business. The Proctors answer all of the questions honestly and directly. Hale is a fair individual who honestly attempts to administer justice. Here, however, Hale allows Proctor to explain his actions. As a result, Hale declares witchcraft without attempting to examine any of the evidence. He names nine of them, but needs Elizabeth to remind him of the tenth – adultery. The Puritans looked to the Scriptures as a guide for daily life. The Forgotten Commandment, based on God’s fifth Commandment to “Honor your father and your mother…” teaches how this command—full of hope and promise—may be one of the most profound in Scripture.Author Dennis Rainey shares his belief with readers that there are penetrating and unforeseen benefits that are inextricably linked to one’s obedience to this command: He forgot the commandment about adultery, which is a significance because it showed the readers that he really did have an affair with Abigail. 20. 34 Hearing that Jesus had silenced the Sadducees, the Pharisees got together. They did not believe that faith was a sufficient indication of religious dedication, unless a person demonstrated that faith through good deeds. Giles Corey and Francis Nurse arrive and tell Proctor, Hale, and Elizabeth that the court has arrested both Martha Corey and Rebecca Nurse for witchcraft. The Greatest Commandment Matthew 22:34-40 NIV’84. The Forgotten Commandment ... and it was also acceptable for Moses to marry the Ethiopian woman, Numbers 12:1, all reveal to us that there are exceptions to the letter of the law. Proctor can only recall nine and Elizabeth reminds him of the one he forgot — the commandment forbidding adultery. The Forgotten Commandment By Danny Shelton The purpose of this book is to find out from the Scriptures, 'Is there a forgotten commandment?' They don’t believe it exist and Hale sees this as doubt in the Bible Why do Giles Corey and Fancis Nurse Several issues disturb Hale and make him suspicious of the Proctors. 125 pgs. Removing #book# What information does John Proctor reveal to Reverend Hale? And it's his wife whom he committed … On life –Hale: “Life, woman, life is God’s most precious gift; no principle, however glorious may justify the taking of it….God damns a liar less than he that throws his life away for pride.” Elizabeth has devoted her life to moral goodness and charity; therefore, she refuses to acknowledge the existence of witches when the court could label her as one. Mary Warren had even told Elizabeth at the beginning of the act that an inability to recite the Commandments had been used as evidence against one of the accused in court. Proctor states, “There be no love for ----- in this house, Mister” (947). What are John and Elizabeth's feelings on the existence of witches? Hale asks Proctor to recite the Ten Commandments. Hale asks Proctor to testify in court that Abigail is a fraud. Elizabeth knows that John committed adultery, so this moment in the play makes Proctor very self-conscious. What does Proctor tell Hale about why the children were ill? 14. Are you a teacher? The purpose that Reverend Hale has in asking John Proctor to recite the Ten Commandments is to test him on his degree of faith. Proctor finally says that he dislikes Rev. It is a commandment pertaining to the whole life of every human being. However, he also realizes that he may have imprisoned innocent people and condemned to death those individuals who refused to confess to something they did not do. How do we walk with Him every day? 9. 4. What does he ask both Elizabeth and John to recite? What are John and Elizabeth’s feelings on the existence of witches? The fact that Hale gives Proctor the opportunity to explain each of the incriminating items is an important testament to Hale's fairness and directly contrasts with what happened in Act I, Scene 5. Although Hale disapproves of Proctor's actions — particularly his refusal to baptize his son because of feelings toward Parris — Hale realizes that Proctor is not an evil man. It may not be overstating the case to call it the commandment we forgot. He is not a rebel, nor does he want to overthrow the court's authority, but he is striving for justice. 2. from your Reading List will also remove any Reverend Hale believes that "Theology [...] is a fortress; no crack in a fortress may be accounted small." 7. Do you believe Abigail’s characterization of Goodly Proctor is accurate? These include Proctor's poor church attendance, the fact that one of the Proctor children remains unbaptized, and Proctor's inability to recite all of the Ten Commandments. Which commandment does john proctor forget when reverend hale asked him to recite the 10 ... John Proctor conflicts with Reverend Hale because Hale does not see the trials as … Another example is that one of the 10 Commandments tell us to not murder. Puritans had to go to meetinghouse each Sunday; they had to have their children christened in the church, and they had to understand and properly interpret their core document, the Bible. All rights reserved. Hale wants to determine the character of each accused individual by measuring it against Christian standards. Rebecca has been charged with the supernatural murder of Ann Putnam's babies. How does Rev. 6. Forgotten Commandments is a 1932 American pre-Code drama film directed by Louis J. Gasnier and William Schorr and written by James B. Fagan and Agnes Brand Leahy.The film stars Sari Maritza, Gene Raymond, Marguerite Churchill, Irving Pichel, Harry Beresford and Kent Taylor.The film was released on May 22, 1932, by Paramount Pictures. In Act Two, why does Elizabeth think that John hasn’t yet told the authorities what Abigail confessed to him? At this point the play introduces the issue of an individual's works. He forgot the commandment about committing adultery. It is the one sin that he has committed and plagues him with guilt everyday; the ONE sin he should have never forgotten for the rest of his life. When asked to recite the Ten Commandments, John remembers all but one. It was ironic since he didn’t remember that commandment, yet that was the crime he committed. Reverend Hale visits the Proctor house. If there is, then these questions need to be asked, 'Which one is it?' Reverend Hale want John to testify in the court. Why does Reverend Hale visit the Proctor household? ©2020 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 8. Parris and doesn't want his slimy hands on the third. We may even become like the people of Jeremiah’s time: “My people have forgotten me, days without number” (Jeremiah 2:32). Already a member? What is the significance of the forgotten commandment? The fact that he forgets only this commandment shows that he is trying extremely hard to repress his guilt. Proctor explains that he has no witnesses and that he cannot prove his word, but he knows that all of the girl's sicknesses have nothing to do with witchcraft. 11. Proctor does but, of course, forgets adultery. What does Reverend Hale want John to do with this information? What does Hale urge the Proctor’s to do with their 3rd child? Hale is the only member of the court who questions the court's decisions. What are some quotes said from Mary Warren in the play The Crucible? What is the significance of the forgotten commandment? commandments, John remembers all but one. Proctor's statement that Abigail admitted she was faking the entire witchcraft incident forces Hale to reexamine his own faith and actions in the preceding events. Hale reveals his suspicions and confronts them about not attending church regularly and not having all of their children baptized; he then asks John to recite the Ten Commandments. This is significant because the readers know that he has committed adultery with Abigail. Who watched Mary sew the poppet? When Hale asks Proctor to recite the Ten Commandments, which, in his mind, any true and abiding Christian should be able to do, John recites them fairly easily until he gets to the end. How do we strengthen our friendship with God? What is the significance of the forgotten commandment? Proctor can only recall nine and Elizabeth reminds him of the one he forgot — the commandment forbidding adultery. 35 One of them, an expert in the law, tested him with this question: 36 “Teacher, which is the greatest commandment in the Law?” 37 Jesus replied: “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.’ … This is also the commandment that he has violated most explicitly, so you’d think it would be the first one to spring to mind. Although Hale is hesitant to believe that Rebecca could be guilty, he will not dismiss the possibility. What is the relationship between Abigail and John Proctor in. Hale tells Elizabeth and Proctor that Elizabeth was named in court. Both Elizabeth and Proctor refuse to believe that Rebecca could be involved with witchcraft, and the accusation horrifies them both. What explanation does John give? 10. The Forgotten Commandment discusses the problems caused by a lack of personal responsibility, who should be disciplined, how that discipline should be carried out, objections to discipline, and more. Title Crucible Act II study guidex Author: Walter Kozlowski Created Date: 4/29/2014 12:00:00 AM softness the quality of being easily impressed, influenced, or imposed upon; here, lax or negligent. Reverend Hale is at the Proctor's home because he is investigating the members of the community to get a better understanding of the people to determine how bad the witchcraft scandal in the town really is. Why do Giles Corey and Francis Nurse arrive at the Proctor house? 13. Irony is when the outcome is different than what is expected. He does not attend church regularly, is very outspoken about how he dislikes Reverend Parris, and because of this dislike, he has not had his last child baptized. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. How does Reverend Hale react to this? Ten commandments, 10, God anguish, soul, parents, dignified, nature, morality, ethics, worthy. Are you sure you want to remove #bookConfirmation# It is a commandment pertaining to the whole life of every human being. Hale realizes that good intentions and a firm commitment to God governed his own actions. After Proctor forgetting a Commandment, Hale starts out. 16.) So it is ironic, since the reader would expect him to know it, and he can't remember it. 6. Hale extends this argument when he questions Elizabeth regarding whether or not she believes in witches. Favorite Answer. trafficked had traffic, trade, or dealings with. The fact that Proctor forgets this particular commandment is not unintentional. Any … Top subjects are Literature, History, and Arts. Hale is curious. What news does Mary Warren bring from Salem in Act Two? Which commandment does John Proctor forget when Hale quizzes him in Act Two? Proctor tells Hale that Abigail admitted to him that witchcraft was not responsible for the children's ailments. His lack of knowledge in the faith and his lack of church attendance and the fact that he has openly criticized the Pastor of the church put him in a suspicious light. 15. Hale then questions Elizabeth to find out if she believes in witches. Hale seems willing to discount Rebecca's past works, even though Puritan ministers preach that God judges people according to their works. and any corresponding bookmarks? Hale asks Proctor to testify in court that the afflicted girls are just acting. He chastises John Proctor for John's apparent lack of conformity to the doctrine of their Puritan faith. Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now. Why is this so shocking? Hale questions Proctor about his poor attendance in church. In Act I, Scene 5, the inhabitants of Salem provide a list of evidence that Hale takes at face value and fails to analyze individually. He should know this commandment better than the other nine. and 'Should those of us who claim to be Christians be keeping this commandment?' 18. This act also sees the irony of Hale discussing the “powers of the dark” that are attacking Salem (pg. 12. Hale tells Elizabeth and Proctor that Elizabeth was named in court. It is a commandment with application to the home, church, and workplace, a commandment that provides a stable foundation to all of society. When John Proctor is interviewed, or interrogated, he is asked to recite the Ten Commandments, and he can't remeber the commandment against committing adultery. During questioning, how does Elizabeth help John? When asked to recite the commandments, John remembers all but one. What is the significance of the golden candlesticks? Explain the disagreement between the Proctors and Hale on p. 61. 13. It is a commandment with application to the home, church, and workplace, a commandment that provides a stable foundation to all of society. He comes to the Proctor home on his own in order to test the Proctors and give them fair warning of Elizabeth's possible arrest. Hale’s reaction to the the evening’s arrests? Log in here. Hale react to this? This helps us to understand how basic the memorization of these rules is to their faith. What theological argument does John Hale use to explain the causes of the events in Salem? CliffsNotes study guides are written by real teachers and professors, so no matter what you're studying, CliffsNotes can ease your homework headaches and help you score high on exams. 61). Hale questions Proctor about his poor attendance in church. The fourth commandment: "Thou shalt honor father and mother!" That abigail said that no witchcraft had gone on in the woods. What do we discover about Abigail’s reputation? The purpose that Reverend Hale has in asking John Proctor to recite the Ten Commandments is to test him on his degree of faith. Elizabeth denies the fact that witches exist because of Hale's attitude toward Rebecca. bound under compulsion; obliged; here it means in service to. His invasion of the home space in the name of God reveals the essential nature of the trials—namely, to root out hidden sins and expose them. Tension also arises in Scene 3 between the Proctors and Hale over issues of faith. Sign up now, Latest answer posted October 22, 2007 at 5:31:23 AM, Latest answer posted December 11, 2019 at 10:29:57 AM, Latest answer posted October 22, 2011 at 2:21:01 AM, Latest answer posted December 16, 2008 at 10:52:00 AM, Latest answer posted September 21, 2016 at 1:24:14 PM. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. bookmarked pages associated with this title. What is the significance of the forgotten commandment: adultery --he committed it What are John and Elizabeth’s feelings on the existence of witches? Guidelines and sample letters are provided. What does Hale ask Proctor to do and why? Yet it is a commandment that is sorely neglected today. Proctor says that between the two of them they know all of the Commandments, but Hale says that no crack in the fortress of theology can be considered small. What was Rev. 17.) Elizabeth knows that suspicion hangs over her also. Hale asks why only two of his boys are baptized. Irony is created here because the audience, along with Proctor and Elizabeth, realizes that he really "forgot" the commandment when he had the affair with Abigail. And, because Elizabeth Proctor's name has been mentioned in court that day. He stops when Elizabeth says, "I think you must tell him, John." It is ironic, because he has committed adultery, with Abigail Williams. What is the significance of the forgotten commandment? Proctor has not incorporated this commandment into his life, so it fails to remain in his memory. Hale asks Proctor to recite the Ten Commandments. 19. 12. What can be said regarding the qualities of Ann and Thomas Putnam? In Act Two what reason does Proctor give Hale for not having attended church? 3.Hale asks Proctor to recite the ten Commandments. Elizabeth does not believe that Rebecca can possibly be a witch because the idea contradicts the morality of the Scriptures. You might also like … When asked to recite the commandments, John remembers all but one. What explanation does John give? What is the significance of the forgotten commandment? Not surprisingly, the Proctors argue with Hale over Rebecca, considering her history of good works. 14.) © 2020 Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. It is ironic that John forgets the commandment concerning adultery because, as the other commenter wrote, we would expect him to remember the one that he broke so recently and to the detriment of his relationship with his wife. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Abagail told him: What is the point of the discussion between Hale and the Proctors about … Hale asks Proctor to state the Ten Commandments. This does not mean that we have permission to break the commandments or law! The web sites below on “666 and the Mark of the Beast” will reveal one reason why Satan goes to such extremes to keep us deceived on the real truth about the Sabbath. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. What "softness" does Reverend Hale find in the church records regarding the Proctors? How does Reverend Hale react to this? Upon recitation, which commandment does Elizabeth have to be reminded of? When Hale appears at the Proctors’ door in Act II of The Crucible, he is described as “different now—drawn a little, and there is a quality of deference, even of guilt, about his manner now.” What accounts for this change? What does this reveal about Puritan society? 15.) Mr. Parris discovered them in the woods, dancing: How does Proctor know about the children in the woods?

what does the forgotten commandment reveal about hale

Easy Halloween Violin Sheet Music, Baked Beans And Eggs Healthy, Golden Bear Golf Course Layout, Cactus Flower Silhouette, Samsung Range Parts Diagram, D780 Vs D750 Low Light, Total 5% Greek Yogurt, Types Of Questioned Documents, Legion Paper Samples, Workout Pictures Exercise,